QUESTIONS:
Final Two Questions:
Assess the changing historical perspectives of Giuseppe Garibaldi's contribution to Italy from 1860 till today.
Pros:
- Just focuses on Giuseppe Garibaldi, so it makes it easier to formulate an answer.
- It would be interesting to see the different perspectives of different groups over time.
Cons:
- The question might be a bit too broad and it will be hard to formulate a concise answer.
- It might be a bit boring to search, as already from my background research it is evident that most perspectives remained positive over time.
To what extent was Giuseppe Garibaldi's contribution critical to the unification of Italy in comparison to Cavour and Mazzini?
Pros:
- It focuses on more than one individual and may allow the extended response to have an interesting outcome.
- With more individuals it gives the response a bigger variation and it won't have a monotonous tone throughout.
- It also forces the response to be less of a recount of one individuals' life and more of a discussion.
- It would be an interesting way to research other contributing individuals to the Unification of Italy while predominantly focusing on one individual.
Cons:
- It may be hard to keep my response concise and make sure that I mainly focus on Giuseppe rather than branching off into other discussions about Cavour and Mazzini.
- Recounting the sequence of events and where the individual's fit into those events.
Final and Revised Question
Assess the role of Giuseppe Garibaldi in the unification of Italy.
- Was Garibaldi a hero or a mercenary?
- Why did Garibaldi go to Southern Italy for the Savoy family?
- Was he a freedom fighter?
- What were his goals? Was it for the money?
- What was his contribution to the unification of Italy?
- What were people's perspectives of him?
- Did he work together with Mazzini and Cavour?
- What was his relationship with Mazzini and Cavour?
- Did he have a bigger contribution on the Unification of Italy than Mazzini and Cavour or was it a collaboration?
- What were the factors that lead to to the revolution?
- Identify the immediate impacts of the revolution.
- Evaluate the political implications of the Unification of Italy today.
- Determine whether Italy would have been the same it is today if it weren't for the revolution?
Final Two Questions:
Assess the changing historical perspectives of Giuseppe Garibaldi's contribution to Italy from 1860 till today.
Pros:
- Just focuses on Giuseppe Garibaldi, so it makes it easier to formulate an answer.
- It would be interesting to see the different perspectives of different groups over time.
Cons:
- The question might be a bit too broad and it will be hard to formulate a concise answer.
- It might be a bit boring to search, as already from my background research it is evident that most perspectives remained positive over time.
To what extent was Giuseppe Garibaldi's contribution critical to the unification of Italy in comparison to Cavour and Mazzini?
Pros:
- It focuses on more than one individual and may allow the extended response to have an interesting outcome.
- With more individuals it gives the response a bigger variation and it won't have a monotonous tone throughout.
- It also forces the response to be less of a recount of one individuals' life and more of a discussion.
- It would be an interesting way to research other contributing individuals to the Unification of Italy while predominantly focusing on one individual.
Cons:
- It may be hard to keep my response concise and make sure that I mainly focus on Giuseppe rather than branching off into other discussions about Cavour and Mazzini.
- Recounting the sequence of events and where the individual's fit into those events.
Final and Revised Question
Assess the role of Giuseppe Garibaldi in the unification of Italy.